Undying Love 1
Reviewed by Martin Skidmore 22-Apr-11
This is an impressive debut issue. The mode is sort of Buffyish, a horror vampire adventure story, though without any of the humour, and for once the attempt to step into that peerless territory doesn’t make your heart sink.
This is an impressive debut issue. The mode is sort of Buffyish, a horror vampire adventure story, though without any of the humour, and for once the attempt to step into that peerless territory doesn’t make your heart sink.
The team co-write, Coker draws, Freedman colours. The story is set in China and Hong Kong, focussing on a white tough guy with a beautiful Chinese vampire girlfriend. It seems in this mythos, she can be cured by consuming the heart of the vampire who made her one, who turns out to be the oldest and mightiest in the land. There is other stuff happening too, featuring a fox spirit and ancient warriors – it gives the impression that they have plenty of material sketched out, though clearly there is a quest with a final goal here. The dialogue is tidy, restrained, clipped, often noirish, and while the main two characters don’t seem to amount to too much so far, there’s an excellent wise man which gives me some optimism that they can do character.
But what lifts it above a competent and promising comic is the lovely art. Coker can genuinely draw – he has the very rare ability to make faces and buildings and so on look as if they are copied really carefully and with great technical skill from photographs, but without any hint of the usual downside of stiffness in composition, movement and flow. His faces have plenty of expression and emotion, quite a few being among the best realistic comic faces I’ve seen in ages (there are two absolute gems on page 10, for instance, and all of them on page 8, pictured, are terrific). With that realism and some aspects of the timings and rhythms, it strikes me as one of the most genuinely cinematic (a much abused term in comic discourse, but I think it is apt here) comics I’ve ever seen. This is helped by an exceptional control of tone and visual mood, both via (presumably computerised) zipatone and texturing and thanks to highly sensitive, muted colouring, heavy on sepia and grey. The overall effect is distinctive, but it did remind me somewhat of some of Gray Morrow’s best work, which is very high praise. Maybe a little reminiscent of some realistic newspaper strip art too, perhaps something like Jim Holdaway on Modesty Blaise – there’s even something I can’t quite define about the graceful toning that made me think of David Wright’s lushly lovely work on Carol Day, though I suspect others may not go along with that, as the technical approach is so different.
I rarely buy comics for art ahead of writing, but the writing here is at least fine and has potential, and the art is often genuinely beautiful, and certainly strikingly effective at conveying the atmosphere and feeling of the story and characters. I just looked up Coker, someone I knew nothing about, and it turns out he has directed some, as well as worked plenty in comics – I may look out some previous work, as he impresses me immensely here.
Tags: Buffy, Daniel Freedman, Image, Tomm Coker, Undying Love
You’re the first person to ever mention Jim Holdaway. I always think his influence stands out but no one seems to know who he is. I’m surprised you didn’t notice any Al Williamson — he’s another HUGE influence. I think most people have forgotten a lot of these guys so they go with whoever is popular at the moment — i.e. I get a lot of Alex Maleeve — whose work I like a lot, but never looked at in more than passing.
Glad you liked the book.
T.
Yes, I can certainly see plenty of Williamson, and I guess I can understand comparisons to Maleev, just about. There are others – I often find when I see a new artist who I really like, I can see lots of possible predecessors, but sometimes listing too many makes it sound as if you think someone is JUST a sum of influences. There are things in your work that isn’t really like any of the people we’ve mentioned – your narrative flow is not like any of them, most notably. The closest I can see to that might be someone like early Frank Miller, but yours is more genuinely cinematic.
Yes, I like it a lot – your work excites me as much as any artist I’ve come across in many years.
The storytelling — for me — is always the most important aspect of any book. Undying Love #2 hits the stands in a few weeks — and in my extremely biased opinion the series only gets better from here.
T.